Ancient Wisdom Today » Shooting the Hevel with Qohelet

A Time to Cast Away

Maer — Thu, 27 Nov 2008 20:00:50 +0000

We often hear of the power of stories, but sometimes it is good to see a specific example of how stories can help us make sense of what could be difficult to grasp in the abstract. They can also stimulate our imagination through their style, play on words, humor, cleverness, ambiguity, etc.

For this reason, I have often wondered what it would be like to transform Qohelet into a narrative. If you think that such a task is impossible or even ludicrous, the Rabbis didn’t think so. Let me show you an example. In chapter 3 Qohelet starts his “catalogue of times” and in verse 6 he says:

[a time to seek, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away (ESV)]

Qohelet and the Human Experience

Maer — Thu, 14 Aug 2008 00:38:57 +0000

One of the crucial considerations when reading Qohelet is whether or not one thinks that the frame narrator is fundamentally criticizing Qohelet and rejecting his arguments. If this is true, then many would say that the bulk of Qohelet should be understood as “life under the sun” and that we, as Christians, should have a heavenly (i. e. above the sun) perspective of life. Ecclesiastes then, for the most part, becomes a how-not-to book. This way, we fail to do what Murphy says we should do, that is, allow for tensions that would have existed within the author himself, and attempt to explain the book as it stands (Murphy, Tree of Life, 52).

However, reading Ecclesiastes as one piece doesn’t seem to be only a matter of allowing for the tensions within the book but also allowing the book to interpret itself. Sometimes this will yield surprising and insightful results.

Shooting the “Hevel” with Qohelet

Maer — Sat, 31 May 2008 23:31:01 +0000

One of my favorite books of the bible is Qohelet (Ecclesiastes). When I was a teenager, I became fascinated with this book, for I thought: “here is a book that is asking hard questions about real life!” Of course, in a sense all books of the bible confront us with hard questions and make us think outside our little boxes, but the style of Qohelet was unlike anything I had read up to that point. But as fascinated as I was with this book, it was also extremely frustrating because it didn’t seem to fit the mold of what a biblical book should look like (or what I thought it should look like) and it raised more questions than it answered.